Fiat 124 Spider vs. Mazda Miata: Why Italy Does Everything Better

Buyer's Guide • Fiat 124 Spider vs Mazda Miata • ND

Same Car,Better Accent

The Fiat 124 Spider is a Miata in an Italian suit. I own one, I've raced against a Miata in it, and I'm here to explain why Italy does everything better. Mostly.

Black Fiat 124 Spider Abarth parked in a racetrack paddock

Fiat 124 Spider vs Mazda Miata — Built in Hiroshima — Italian Turbo — Japanese Chassis — Mopar on the Dash — Italian Leather — German Seats — Identity Crisis — Better Accent — Fiat 124 Spider vs Mazda Miata —

The question everyone asks me

Isn't That Just a Miata?

Every time I park my black 124 Spider Abarth, someone walks up and says, "Isn't that just a Miata?" And every time, I say the same thing: yes. And also no. And also, how dare you.

Here's the deal. Fiat and Mazda made a deal in the mid-2010s, and the result was the Fiat 124 Spider. It's built by Mazda in Hiroshima, on the same ND platform as the fourth-generation MX-5 Miata. Same chassis, same basic interior, same soft top, same six-speed manual. Then Fiat gave it its own engine, its own suspension tuning and a body that looks like it just walked out of a café in Turin.

I've owned mine, which I named Veleno, for a while now. I've taken it to the track, replaced a mirror that required taking the whole door apart and raced it at autocross against my old Miata. So I've earned an opinion. Here it is.

A car with an identity crisis

Japanese, Italian, American and a Little Bit German

Let's be honest about what this car is. It's a cultural exchange program with a convertible top.

The VIN is Japanese, because Mazda built it in Hiroshima. The engine is Italian, a Fiat 1.4-liter MultiAir turbo. The styling is Italian, from Centro Stile Fiat, with nods to the Pininfarina-designed 124 Sport Spider from 1966. The leather is Italian. And then you look at the dash and there's a Mopar logo, because the company that sold it was Fiat Chrysler. Mine even has Recaro seats, so Germany got a seat at the table too.

Fun fact: according to Wikipedia, this car was originally supposed to be an Alfa Romeo. It became a Fiat because Alfas are supposed to be built in Italy. So technically, I drive a Japanese-built, Italian-engined, American-sold Alfa Romeo that changed its name at the last minute. That's not an identity crisis. That's a passport collection.

Red fourth-generation Mazda MX-5 Miata ND roadster, front three-quarter view
The Mazda MX-5 Miata (ND). Clean, simple, friendly. It looks like it wants to be your friend. Photo: Kickaffe (Mario von Berg) via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0
Black Fiat 124 Spider Abarth with an Italian tricolor hood stripe parked indoors
The Fiat 124 Spider Abarth. Longer hood, meaner face, tricolor stripe. It looks like it wants to borrow your sunglasses and keep them.

Head to head

The Numbers

I'm a CPA. I don't argue with feelings. I argue with spreadsheets. Car and Driver tested a 2017 124 Spider Abarth against a 2016 Miata Club, and here's how they stacked up, with a few other specs added.

Spec SheetFiat 124 SpiderMazda MX-5 (ND)
Built byMazda, HiroshimaMazda, Hiroshima
Engine1.4L MultiAir turbo four (Fiat)2.0L Skyactiv four, no turbo
Power160 hp (Abarth: 164)155 hp (2016–18), 181 hp (2019+)
Torque184 lb-ft at 2,500 rpm148–151 lb-ft
Curb weight (C/D test)2,509 lb (Abarth)2,316 lb (Club)
0–60 mph (C/D test)6.7 sec6.2 sec
70–0 mph braking (C/D test)171 ft175 ft
Skidpad (C/D test)0.87 g0.89 g
Length159.6 in154.1 in
Trunk4.9 cu ft4.6 cu ft
U.S. model years2017–20202016–present
U.S. sales, total15,778Lots. Everyone has one.

Green = the winner on that line. Test numbers are from Car and Driver's 2017 Fiat 124 Spider Abarth vs. 2016 Mazda MX-5 Miata Club comparison. Engine, length, trunk and sales figures are from Wikipedia and SlashGear. Rarity counts as a win. I make the rules here.

Where the Miata wins

Okay, Fine. The Miata Is Faster.

I'll be the honest one. Car and Driver picked the Miata. It's about 190 pounds lighter in their test, it hit 60 half a second sooner and it pulled harder on the skidpad. The Miata's 2.0-liter engine revs out to 7,500 rpm and answers the throttle instantly. Since 2019, it makes 181 horsepower, which beats the Fiat outright.

The Miata also feels more direct. Car and Driver found it the more charming of the two. And you can buy a new one today. Fiat stopped selling the 124 in North America after 2020.

If you want the purest, lightest, revviest version of this car, buy the Miata. I mean that.

Where Italy wins

Why Italy Does Everything Better

Torque. The Fiat's turbo makes 184 lb-ft at 2,500 rpm, compared to the Miata's 148 to 151. You feel it every time you pull out of a stop sign. You don't have to wring its neck to make it go. It's a lazy Sunday car that turns into a mean little rocket when you ask nicely.

It's more comfortable. Car and Driver said the Fiat had better seats and more insulation. It's quieter on the highway, and it rides better on Montana roads that look like they were paved by a guy with a shovel.

It stops shorter. 171 feet from 70 mph, versus 175 for the Miata. Four feet. That's a deer's worth.

It's prettier. Longer hood, power bulges, a face like a 1960s Italian roadster. The Miata is cute. The Fiat is handsome. There's a difference, and everybody at the gas station knows it.

It's rare. Fiat sold 15,778 of them in the U.S. Every Cars & Coffee has three Miatas. You'll go years without seeing another 124. When you do, you wave.

The Abarth sounds like it's angry. The Miata hums. The Abarth crackles and pops like it's mad about something. It's always mad about something. It's Italian.

Rear view of a black Fiat 124 Spider Abarth with quad exhaust tips
Quad exhaust tips. The Miata has two. Italy has more of everything, including opinions.
Rear view of an all-black 1999 Mazda Miata, the Love Miata
My old Miata, the Love Miata. I've raced against it at autocross in the Fiat. I'll let you guess who I'm rooting for.

Real talk

What to Know Before You Buy a 124

Used 124s are out there, mostly priced around where a similar used Miata is. SlashGear puts them around $20,000. Check the real market before you buy, because prices move.

Buy the Abarth if you can. It's the one with the attitude. Get the manual. The automatic exists. Don't. Check the parts situation. Fiat-specific parts like the engine and body panels come from a brand that left the U.S. market, so plan ahead. Anything Mazda-shared is easy. And don't let anyone tell you it's just a Miata. Agree with them, then drive away faster than they expected.

The verdict

Italy Wins. Obviously.

Is the Miata the better sports car? Probably. Is it faster, lighter and easier to live with? Yes. Car and Driver said so, and I believe them.

But the 124 is the one with a story. It's a Japanese car with an Italian heart, American paperwork and German seats, and it makes every drive feel like an event. It's the Miata that went to Europe for a semester and came back wearing a scarf.

I'd buy mine again tomorrow. Italy wins. Not on the stopwatch. On everything else.

124 or Miata?

Which side are you on? Own a 124? Tell me what you love and what broke. Own a Miata? Tell me why I'm wrong. I can take it.

Miata photo from Wikimedia Commons, credited under the image. Fiat photos are mine.

Drive Fast · Take Chances · Never Lift.

Previous
Previous

It Went to Prom: A 34k-Mile, Renaissance Red 1998 Lexus SC 400 on Cars & Bids

Next
Next

The Celica Is Back: Toyota Confirms a New GR Celica for the 2027 WRC